← TARA: exam page
TARA · Writing Task · independent practice feedback

TARA Writing Task feedback: your answer read part by part

Write your answer to a TARA-style statement under the 40-minute clock and get a band and written comments on each part of the task, with quotes from your answer and a rewrite for each area below Strong.

3task parts checked5areas, each banded40minute clock2feedback runs
  • Built on UAT-UK's own advice
  • Quotes from your answer
  • Rewrites to try
  • Three priorities
Five areas, each with its own bandSee a sample report

UAT-UK does not mark the Writing Task. This is feedback against our rubric, not a TARA score.

Feedback on your Writing Task answer
₹1,4992 feedback runs

In the TARA you choose one of three statements and have 40 minutes and at most 750 words to explain what it means, argue against it and say how far you agree. UAT-UK does not mark this part: it sends a copy of your answer to the universities you applied to for courses that require the TARA, and its results page says how they use it is at their discretion. This tool gives you independent feedback on a practice answer, part by part, against a rubric we built on the recommendations in UAT-UK's TARA Question Guide.

1. Choose a statement

In the test you choose one of three statements; here you choose from a practice pool of seven.

2. Answer all three parts

The most valuable thing a university can teach is how to change your mind.
  1. Explain what you think is meant by the statement.
  2. Give a reasoned argument against the statement.
  3. To what extent do you agree with the statement?

UAT-UK suggests planning for 5 to 10 minutes and grouping your ideas around the three parts. In the test there is no dictionary or spell-checker, so we switch the browser's spell-check off here too.

40:000 / 750 words

Get feedback on your answer

  • A band in five areas: explaining the statement, the argument against, your view, organisation, clarity
  • Quotes from your answer showing what the next band needs, and a rewritten passage for each area below Strong
  • Three priorities for your next answer, and what to keep
  • 2 runs: your answer, then a rewrite to see what changed
₹1,499one-time · 2 feedback runs

Your draft stays in this browser until you press the feedback button after unlocking. Nothing is sent before that.

Free: a sample report, with notes

This is the report our tool gave on one of our calibration answers, a mid-level answer to the statement below, unedited apart from the green notes. Our reviewers placed this answer at Developing for the explanation and Secure elsewhere; the tool read three areas one band differently, which is the kind of difference to expect. Read the answer first, then the report.

Read the answer (405 words)

This statement is saying that the most important thing you can learn at university is how to change your mind. This means being open-minded and listening to other people's opinions instead of just sticking to what you already think. In today's world, where there are lots of different opinions, this is a very important skill.

However, there is an argument against this statement. The main purpose of a university is to give students knowledge about their subject. For example, a medical student needs to learn about the human body, diseases and treatments, and if they do not learn this then they cannot be a good doctor, no matter how open-minded they are. Employers also want graduates who have skills and knowledge that they can use in the job. So it could be argued that knowledge is more valuable than learning to change your mind. Also, some people might say that changing your mind too much is a bad thing, because people who change their mind all the time are not reliable and cannot make decisions.

On the other hand, I think that learning to change your mind is very important. In my opinion, being open-minded is a key skill in life and at university. For example, at university you will meet people from many different backgrounds and countries, and you will hear many opinions that are different from yours. If you cannot change your mind, you will not learn from these people. Also, scientists have to change their mind when new evidence comes out, for example when astronomers accepted that the Earth goes around the Sun and not the other way round. This shows that changing your mind is how knowledge moves forward.

Furthermore, the world is changing very quickly, and a lot of the facts that students learn will be out of date in a few years. Therefore it is more useful to learn how to think and how to change your mind than to just learn facts. Knowledge is important but it is not the most important thing.

In conclusion, I mostly agree with the statement. Although knowledge is important, and a medical student needs knowledge to be a doctor, learning how to change your mind is the most valuable thing because it helps you in every part of your life and it is how knowledge moves forward. Universities should teach students to be open-minded so they can keep learning after they graduate.

Your profile on this answer

The most valuable thing a university can teach is how to change your mind.

405 words · confidence of this read: medium

  • Explained the statement
  • Argued against it
  • Said to what extent you agree
AreaBand
Explaining the statement Secure
The argument against Developing
Your view and how well it is supported Secure
Organisation Strong
Clarity and precision Secure

Your answer is clearly organised and gives a reasoned, mostly-agree position, with relevant examples. The main limits are that one counter-point is only asserted and the explanation of what it means to change your mind could be more precise.

Margin notes in green explain how to read each part of the report.

Explaining the statement: Secure

The band is set from the whole answer against our descriptor for this area; the sentence below says which descriptor it rests on.

The explanation is clear and defines changing your mind as listening to others, but it leaves important limits and the comparison in most valuable unexplored.

You explain the skill as listening to other opinions rather than simply holding to an existing view. This means being open-minded and listening to other people's opinions instead of just sticking to what you already think.

This means being open-minded and listening to other people's opinions instead of just sticking to what you already think.

For the next band, distinguish thoughtful revision from changing a view whenever someone disagrees, and explain that most valuable compares this skill with everything else a university might teach.

Every quote is copied from the answer; a quote the reader cannot find in it is removed before the report is shown.

Keep this sentence and add after it

This means being open-minded and listening to other people's opinions instead of just sticking to what you already think.

The statement need not mean accepting every opinion: it can mean revising a view when stronger reasons or evidence persuade you. It also compares this skill with everything else a university might teach, rather than saying subject knowledge has no value.

The argument against: Developing

The case against the statement has one explained ground about the value of subject knowledge, while the concern about changing your mind too much is not developed.

The medical-student example explains why subject knowledge is needed, and you connect that to the argument that knowledge may be more valuable. a medical student needs to learn about the human body, diseases and treatments, and if they do not learn this then they cannot be a good doctor

Also, some people might say that changing your mind too much is a bad thing, because people who change their mind all the time are not reliable and cannot make decisions.

This gives a second relevant ground, but the next band needs it explained; show how frequent changes without good reasons could make others unable to rely on a person's decisions.

Keep this sentence and add after it

Also, some people might say that changing your mind too much is a bad thing, because people who change their mind all the time are not reliable and cannot make decisions.

For example, if someone keeps reversing a decision without new reasons, other people may not be able to plan around it. The problem is not changing a view when there is a good reason, but changing it so often that no decision can be trusted.

Where a part is thin, the suggestion is added after the writer's sentence, which stays; a replacement aims to sharpen the writer's own point; check that any suggested wording keeps your argument and position.

Your view and how well it is supported: Secure

You clearly mostly agree and briefly judge that changing your mind matters more than subject knowledge because it remains useful as facts change.

You recognise the value of subject knowledge but explain why you rank the ability to change your mind above it. Therefore it is more useful to learn how to think and how to change your mind than to just learn facts.

Although knowledge is important, and a medical student needs knowledge to be a doctor, learning how to change your mind is the most valuable thing

For the next band, develop the comparison between the need for subject knowledge and the wider, lasting use you give to changing your mind, rather than stating the ranking briefly.

Keep this sentence and add after it

Knowledge is important but it is not the most important thing.

Subject knowledge is essential in fields such as medicine, but the ability to revise what one knows can remain useful as facts change. That wider and lasting use is why I rank it higher, not because knowledge is unimportant.

Organisation: Strong

The answer moves in a clear order from meaning, to objections, to support for your view and a conclusion that reaches an overall judgement.

Each part has a clear place, and the final paragraph uses the earlier points about knowledge and changing your mind to support your position. In conclusion, I mostly agree with the statement.

Clarity and precision: Secure

The meaning is clear throughout, though a few broad phrases are less precise than they could be.

Your points and examples are easy to follow, including the contrast between learning facts and learning to change your mind. Knowledge is important but it is not the most important thing.

a lot of the facts that students learn will be out of date in a few years.

The meaning is clear, but the next band needs more exact wording; replace the broad phrase a lot of with many.

One way to rewrite it

a lot of the facts that students learn will be out of date in a few years.

many facts that students learn will be out of date in a few years.

Three priorities for your next answer

  1. The argument against: Explain how changing a decision repeatedly without a good reason could make a person unreliable and unable to act. This helps meet the counter-argument descriptor by developing a second relevant ground rather than only asserting it.
  2. Explaining the statement: Clarify that changing your mind means revising a belief for good reasons, not simply accepting every different opinion, and explain what most valuable compares. This helps meet the statement descriptor by exploring the key terms and the scope of the claim.
  3. Your view and how well it is supported: Explain more fully why the lasting usefulness of changing your mind outweighs the need for subject knowledge, while keeping your mostly-agree position. This helps meet the view descriptor by developing your judgement about the relative weight of both sides.

Keep doing this

  • You answer all three parts and state your position clearly.
  • The medical-student example gives a concrete reason why subject knowledge matters.
  • You support your view with relevant points about learning from others, scientific change and facts becoming outdated.

Feedback against our rubric, built on UAT-UK's published Writing Task recommendations. UAT-UK does not mark the Writing Task, so this is not a TARA score or a forecast of how a university will read your answer.

Free: the rubric

Every answer is read against these descriptors. The areas follow the three parts of the task and the six groups of recommendations in UAT-UK's TARA Question Guide (General, Planning, Engaging with the statement, Arguing effectively, The counter-argument, Expressing your view). The wording and the bands are ours.

These are our practice bands only. UAT-UK does not mark the Writing Task, and these bands are not a TARA score: UAT-UK's 1.0 to 9.0 scale applies only to Critical Thinking and Problem Solving.

  • The descriptors and bands are our own assessment choices, built on UAT-UK's published recommendations.
  • Each area is judged across the whole answer. The three parts can be answered separately or together; UAT-UK says there is no single correct way to approach the task.
  • A missing part gets its lowest band in its own area and is reported as missing. It does not by itself lower Explaining the statement, Organisation or Clarity. But Your view weighs the considerations the answer has developed, so it cannot go above Secure if no consideration against the writer's position is developed anywhere. That is an upper limit, not an entitlement: Secure still needs its own descriptor to be met.
  • A blank answer, or one that does not attempt the task, gets the lowest band in every area.
  • Repetition of whole points counts under Organisation only. Material that does not explain the statement, argue or support the view earns nothing, and where it crowds out relevant material it counts against the area it displaces.
  • The case against the statement is judged before any rebuttal: answering an objection, or arguing for the statement elsewhere, does not lower that area.
  • Detailed subject knowledge is not needed (UAT-UK says so): everyday or clearly explained examples can support strong reasoning, and specialist references earn nothing by themselves. A good example counts wherever it appears. In the test there is no dictionary or spell-checker; spelling and grammar count only as far as they get in the way of the meaning.
  • Not banded: planning. UAT-UK suggests planning for 5 to 10 minutes and grouping your ideas around the three parts; a finished answer cannot show whether you planned, so it is advice, not a band. The 750-word limit is flagged separately.
Explaining the statement · Explain what you think is meant by the statement.

Built on UAT-UK's recommendations: “Engage closely with the wording of the statement and the question.” “Take a broad and nuanced view of any general or abstract terms.” “Avoid discussing the topic area in an unfocused or overly general way.”

  • Strong. Explains the claim accurately and examines the key terms, assumptions and scope that matter to the argument; where a term is broad, abstract or ambiguous in a way that affects the argument, the relevant senses or limits are distinguished, and the reading chosen is used consistently. The explanation sets up the rest of the answer.
  • Secure. A clear, accurate explanation in which at least one key term or limit is explicitly defined or delimited, but another term, sense or limit that matters to the argument is left unexplored.
  • Developing. The general claim is accurately paraphrased, but no key term is defined or delimited beyond restating the topic (a synonym or a face-value dictionary definition does not count as defining or delimiting), or unfocused discussion of the topic crowds out the explanation of this statement.
  • Limited. An attempt at an explanation, but it misrepresents the claim or is only loosely related discussion of the topic: no accurate paraphrase of this statement can be found.
  • Not addressed. No attempt to explain what the statement means.
The argument against · Give a reasoned argument against the statement.

Built on UAT-UK's recommendations: “Strengthen the counter-argument by including a range of points.” “Cover different aspects of the same argument from different angles, where possible.” “Avoid the inclusion of irrelevant background information.” “Use targeted, concrete examples to support your arguments.” “Avoid arguments that rest solely on examples – examples should not be overly general or given without context.”

  • Strong. A sustained, well-supported case against the statement: distinct relevant grounds, or different aspects of one central objection, developed with no material gap. Central claims about how the world works are backed by a targeted example, concrete detail or a clear causal explanation (no detailed subject knowledge needed); examples support the reasoning and never replace it.
  • Secure. A coherent case against the statement: two explained grounds, or one ground explained through two distinct aspects, but relevant aspects are left unexplored or one material link is only asserted.
  • Developing. One explained ground against the statement; any further grounds are only asserted or rest on examples left unexplained.
  • Limited. Opposition is mentioned but no relevant reason for it is explained (for example, it is raised only to be dismissed), or the "objection" does not actually count against the statement.
  • Not addressed. No attempt to argue against the statement.
Your view and how well it is supported · To what extent do you agree with the statement?

Built on UAT-UK's recommendations: “Make sure that your view is clearly expressed and in enough depth.” “Support your view by reference to your arguments in the rest of your answer.” “Do not simply summarise what you have already said.” “Always try to see both sides of the argument.”

  • Strong. A clear, precise answer to "to what extent" (full agreement or disagreement is fine when it is justified), reached by weighing considerations on both sides that the answer has developed, and supported by its reasoning, drawing on relevant examples where they help. It adds judgement rather than repeating what was said.
  • Secure. A clear position supported by a reasoned judgement about the relative weight, reach or limits of competing considerations that it names (not just "mostly" or "more important"), though that judgement is only briefly developed.
  • Developing. An identifiable position supported by at least one explained reason (an example can illustrate a reason but not replace it), but without explaining how the competing considerations affect the position.
  • Limited. An answer to how far the writer agrees is attempted, but the position is unclear or inconsistent, or rests on no explained reason.
  • Not addressed. No answer to the question of how far the writer agrees.
Organisation · the whole answer

Built on UAT-UK's recommendations: “Ensure that all three parts of the question are clearly and fully addressed.” “Group similar points together, rather than splitting them across your answer.” “Make points as precisely as possible and avoid repetition.”

  • Strong. Each substantive point is placed once, where it does its main job; related points are grouped and the connections give a clear progression. Treating the three parts separately or together are both fine.
  • Secure. The progression is generally clear, but at least one point is misplaced, split or repeated, so the reader has to relocate it mentally.
  • Developing. Frequent fragmentation, repetition or unclear connections mean the reader has to reconstruct the argument.
  • Limited. Persistent problems of organisation stop the reader following the argument reliably.
Clarity and precision · the whole answer

Built on UAT-UK's recommendations: “Use your plan to ensure you express your ideas as persuasively and concisely as possible.”

  • Strong. Wording is exact and economical within each point, and no expression's meaning has to be inferred; minor errors do not interrupt reading.
  • Secure. Isolated vague, wordy or awkward expressions whose meaning is still immediately clear; errors do not interrupt reading.
  • Developing. Meaning is generally recoverable, but unclear expression or errors obscure a substantive point or repeatedly interrupt reading.
  • Limited. The meaning is often unclear because of loose expression or errors.

Before you buy

Is this a TARA score?

No. UAT-UK does not mark the Writing Task. Its results page says the answer is passed to the universities you apply to if they require the test, and that how they use it is at their discretion (UAT-UK results page, read 16 Nov 2026). Our bands are feedback against our own rubric, not a score, and not a forecast of how a university will read your essay.

How is my answer read?

Against the rubric on this page: five areas, each with a band from Limited to Strong. The three task-part areas can also be Not addressed, if that part is missing; Organisation and Clarity run from Limited to Strong. The areas follow the three parts of the task and the recommendations in UAT-UK's TARA Question Guide. The reader is our automated reader, instructed with the rubric and anchored on six calibration answers whose bands were settled per area as the median of our target band and blind readings by two independent reviewer families over three rounds. It quotes your answer for every point it makes, and a quote it cannot find in your answer is removed before you see the report.

How reliable is it?

We tested it on six calibration answers (two strong, two mid-level, two weak) whose bands were settled per area as the median of our target band and blind readings by two independent reviewer families over three rounds. Each answer was read with itself left out of the examples. In our two latest checks (16 Nov 2026), 23 and 26 of the 30 area bands matched exactly and all 30 were within one band each time; no weak answer was placed above a strong one in any area. Where it differed, it was by one band, in either direction. This is a small calibration set, so results on other answers may differ. Treat a band as a well-informed second opinion: the quotes and rewrites are there so you can check every point against your own answer.

What do I get for the price?

2 feedback runs: one for your first answer and one for a rewrite, so you can see whether the changes worked. Each run gives the profile, the evidence, a rewrite for each area below Strong, and three priorities. Your past reports stay on this page.

Can I use my own statement?

Not yet: you choose from seven statements, six written by us in the style UAT-UK describes and UAT-UK's own sample statement. The rubric is the same for all of them.

What happens to my answer?

It stays in this browser until you press the feedback button after unlocking. It is then sent for feedback and saved with the report so you can read it again. It is never published. If you delete your account, your answers and reports are deleted too.

I have the TARA practice test. Is this included?

No, it is a separate purchase. The practice test has a Writing Task prompt with a clock but no feedback; if you wrote an answer there, it is filled in here for you. The TARA Writing Task guide has three annotated example essays for free.

Disclaimer

Who makes this? ProSyllabus, independently. It is not produced, endorsed or checked by UAT-UK, the University of Oxford or UCL. The statements are original except UAT-UK's sample statement, which is quoted from its TARA Question Guide.